In this unusual case of stolen identity between two brothers, Judge Philippe has to decide who is telling the truth: the plaintiff, the older brother Timothée Suter; or the defendant, his younger brother Cédric Suter, who claims he is innocent.

Timothée receives a summons for insulting a police officer and tells the judge it was his brother Cédric who committed the crime, as the incident occurred outside Cédric's building. But Cédric claims his brother was there too...

Judge Philippe begins to make sense of the brothers' very different versions of the events. Timothée finally has to admit he was lying...

Timothée Suter was caught lying, and this is not helping his case. The judge is beginning to think he fabricated the whole identity theft story to hurt his brother.

An additional witness testifies against the plaintiff Timothée, which incriminates him even further. But there's about to be a twist in the case that will call everything into question.

Cédric's downstairs neighbor has just reversed her testimony, which changes everything. Will it be enough to prove Timothée's innocence?